Saturday 28 February 2015

Domesticity. And radical social change.

A long time ago, a friend of mine and I sat talking about our future. At that time life was just opening up in a million exciting ways and exploding in all directions – both good and bad. We sat on a little wooden bench in a tiny shed in the remote and stunningly beautiful hillsides of the Chhotanagpur plateau wondering what the future held for us. Twenty years down the line who would we be? Where would we be? We felt it may be an easier task to have a hold on what we would not do, rather than what we would. And my friend and I then set ourselves 3 indicators, which we swore to avoid.  These indicators, true to our then somewhat romantic and intellectual pretensions, took the detailed shape of these 3 visions:
1.    We were standing in a poorly lit kitchen, hair coming loose from a hastily tied bun, wearing a synthetic saree with a blouse that was not matching, cooking over a blackened ‘kadhai’. We looked fatigued and virtuous.
2.    We were running after our infant children, with morsels of food in our hands, pleading and cajoling them to eat a little – just a little, ma. We looked dumpy and virtuous.
3.    We were meeting after 10 years and our conversation was limited to nappies and recipes. We looked vacuous and virtuous.
We made a pact right then, and promised to avoid doing all the above three and use these as our indicators of failure in the years to come. Our joint horror of domesticity, the influence of Bollywood and our own rather non conventional mothers are visible in the details and nature of these three indicators.
Did we succeed? I would say yes. Has it been easy? No. The pressure to conform is immense.
In the twenty years that have elapsed  since that day, my friend and I stayed faithful to our pact. We have stuck to avoiding our indicators, sometimes slipping close to one, sometimes making herculean efforts to avoid another and often, standing aloof and apart and watching with disbelief as other eminently sensible friends and family ticked off one indicator after the other. “Why can’t you be like everyone else?” has been a comment we have heard often. “Why can’t others be like us?” my friend and I have wailed.
And in these twenty years, these carefully detailed indicators (our apologies to all readers who wear synthetic sarees) have turned out to be one of the most potent influences in my life. Every time convention and custom called one of these indicators would rear its head. For example, as I prepared for a parent teacher meeting, chose a plain saree and tied my hair in a severe bun to look the role of a sincere and hardworking parent, one of these visions would rise up in all its melodramatic flamboyance,  and  I would hastily back track. Mostly I have arrived at parent teacher meetings looking, well, let’s say, different from everyone else in the room.
Just in case the reader is beginning to imagine us as anarchists or feminists or activists or all of them together and pictures of austere, angst ridden, dowdily dressed, statistics quoting middle aged women are beginning to take shape in your head, let me assure you that only the middle aged, feminist and activist bits are true. Both my friend and I are proud home makers and contented parents to 2 children. Our homes are full of things we love – books, music, children, friends, family, dogs, gardens, paintings, maps, food and more books. We have travelled the world. Like most others, we have had our share of good times and the bad. If you meet us now, you will see two contented, eccentric, determined women, with a clear and usually singular opinion on most things in life and not shy of voicing them, ready for a good laugh and a good trip, a good book and a good cup of tea. We are mostly tranquil, sometimes grumpy and yes, a few times also sad. We have our kitchens (excellent ones, mind you) but have not been limited to them. We have our children (lovely ones, you’ll see) but have not been limited by them. We have our conversations (soul satisfying, as always) but they are never virtuous. By our standards, we succeeded.
And since this is a blog about my own experiences, I cannot end by only telling you that we succeeded. I must tell you how I succeeded.  Here then, are my tried and tested strategies of response when conformism and virtuosity are leaning heavily on your door. Mostly such bulwarks of social stability exist in the form of the general population who spend an immense amount of resources trying to get you to follow the herd. When they do,
1.    Learn to smile. But smile knowingly and enigmatically. Most people find women who smile knowingly a little scary, if not creepy. Do note the difference between smiling ‘nicely’ and smiling ‘knowingly.’ The latter has an element of superiority. Smile especially in times of anger. Hide your anger, but show your smile. When I have responded with anger, the argument has turned righteous and virtuous, and I have been left isolated, furious and worst – I have lost the argument. But when I have remained silent and smiled slowly and knowingly, I have always won the argument. Additional benefit of this strategy: Enjoy the confusion one creates by choosing not to respond exactly at the time when people are gathering around to watch you explode. 
2.    Pick a non committal word or phrase that allows you to respond, but not give anything away. Like “Really?” or “Is that so?” or “Indeed.” My mother tongue, Bengali has an outstanding phrase in this category –“Tai, na?” Apologies to my non Bengali speaking readers – it is almost impossible to translate. The primary objective here is to refrain from committing to anything you will regret later and/or participate in a pointless argument. The combination of this phrase with Point # 1 or with a raised eyebrow can give you 95% success.
3.    Have role models of who you do not want to become. That works better than having role models of whom you do want to become. If social pressure becomes too much and you start thinking of replacing your one dish party menu with a 4 course sit down meal, instead of sensibly completing the chapter of the book you were reading, train yourself to respond to this situation by remembering Auntie M.
4.    Have the correct friends. This one is the most important.
Since you will definitely benefit from this short hand book on initiating radical social change, do return the favour and share your strategies too.